Every couple of hours I read
a post of Facebook wherein parents describe the explanations they
give their kids for why diapers need to be changed, or we all need to
go outside, or it's time to leave the park, or go to school, or get
out of bed, or go to bed, or put on shoes, or pack up for dance
class... or whatever.
“You want to go to
class...”
“If you don't, your bum
will get sore...”
“It's good for your body
to be out in the sunlight, moving around...”
“Besides, you like the
seaside...”
One of the recommended
techniques to improve not only a child's vocabulary but also their
ability to think for life is to chatter away at them about what is
going on, what things are called, their descriptions, how they
function, etc. Pointing out the world and describing it theoretically
gives kids the mental framework they need to assemble their thoughts
in order to understand what is going on around them...
...which is all well and
good, up to a point.
That point is where parents are trying to
convince them that a parent's ideas of what should happen next is a super great idea that all sane children will leap to agree
with.
Is this where I mention that
kids (especially little kids, but let's be honest: people of all
ages) are not noted for their sanity?
Even after decades of study
in marketing and the science of influencing people, adults struggle to
convince other adults to switch to Pepsi or wear their seatbelts...
and yet we expect to talk a busy toddler into changing activities
while they're doing what they want to do. This is not rational.
And, more importantly, it
doesn't work. Pretty much ever.
No child is going to be sold
on the 'fun' of cleaning up their room, or putting the dishes in the
sink, or going outside when they are happily exploring the texture of
the carpet.
What Actually Works, Ever
(not 100%, because, see above, re: sanity)
Get the child's attention.
Announce.
Wait.
Wait a little while longer.
Get the child's
attention
When they're busy experimenting with the light and shadow on the tile by the door, their minds are not open to what else is going on... so to them, dad chattering away in the background is like talk radio in a different language that you can hear from someone's passing car.
When they're busy experimenting with the light and shadow on the tile by the door, their minds are not open to what else is going on... so to them, dad chattering away in the background is like talk radio in a different language that you can hear from someone's passing car.
Get down on the child's
level, in front of the child so you are within sight. Touch the child
gently. Wait until they make eye contact.
Announce
Just say what is coming up,
with the first direction you need them to follow:
'Shoes on, we're going to
the grocery store.'
'Time for a diaper change,
meet me over there...'
'Get what you need for
skating lessons.'
Wait
Simple enough. Hard to do.
It helps to sit still and not say anything at all. Adding words or
movement at this point is distracting from what you've just said is
going to happen, and suggests that it isn't, actually... It suggests that
something has happened to make that go away (because things do that
all the time –I'm talking to you
In-5-minutes-we-will-leave-where-mummy-is-talking-to-friends, and we
don't go anywhere for 23 minutes!)
Things are moving inside
where you can't see them. Gears are shifting, and because they are
little and have hardly any practice, it takes a while. Watch their
face ponder what you've said, and wait while it's integrated into
their world in there.
They want to get along, they
want to be part of the big world. They want to be clean and happy and
fed and have a variety of experiences. They just don't want to be
rushed.
They really don't want to be
convinced.
Just wait. Just watch.
I've also had limited success with a sincere request for help. pause. pause. Would you like to help me? useful responses to proceeding are: maybe or yes. Then the next request: Would you be willing to (bla)? responses: maybe or why. because it would make me happy to know that you're going to have a clean diaper, time outside, etc. (note the honesty).
ReplyDeleteHmmm... my reply to this seems to have disappeared...
ReplyDeleteThe "sincere request for help" isn't... a request, or sincere, or help, usually. Or all 3.
Some people have been convinced that issuing orders is wrong or ineffective (orders ARE effective, just only for inflaming resistance) and "giving options" that aren't really options, or "asking" ... but the point is still "do what I want you to do"...
While it sounds like it will honestly "make parent happy" if parent gets their own way, the fact remains that people who get their own way aren't happy, they are miserable. And "if you comply with my [ahem, orders] in my time, I will be happy [with your behaviour]" is kind of emotional blackmail. The last reason a child should bend to the will of an adult is "to make an adult happy."
The flip side is more true: I am concerned about your dirty diaper causing problems... but that is still beyond most kids' reality (later is another person's country)...
There is a follow up post, called Part 2, that may help more.